On November 7th, 2024, the Appraisers Association of America (AAA) hosted an enlightening panel featuring Susan Hunter (moderator), Karin Gross (IRS Counsel), and Meredith Meuwley, AAS (Art Advisory Services). The panel discussed critical updates and best practices for appraisers preparing reports for gift, estate, and non-cash charitable contributions, highlighting the importance of professionalism, due diligence, and adherence to IRS guidelines. Below is a detailed summary and analysis of the discussion, crafted for CPAs, personal property appraisers, and most importantly, the taxpayer.

It appears to be typical of any IRS codification or procedural direction, that the end result must be confusion. Obtaining clarification may involve hours of wait-time to speak to a real person or a head-first dive down the rabbit hole of reading scholarly articles on a CPA or tax attorney’s interpretation of said codification. When it comes to appraisers, they may inadvertently interpret IRS publications incorrectly and expose the client to risk for an audit and the subsequent loss of their non-monetary charitable contribution deduction due to failure to procure proper documentation.